Physician enthuses about the iPad mini, but admits keyboard could give Surface the edge

by Doug Drinkwater

January 23 2013

The larger iPad can be "hard to carry around", according to Vineet Arora MD

Apple’s iPad mini was initially pitched as a consumer device and, while it's doing fine in that regard, physicians are increasingly finding Apple's 7.85-inch tablet useful as well.

In a blog post for, internal medicine physician Vineet Arora explains the advantages and disadvantages of using the iPad mini for work, having received one recently as a gift.

Like many other physicians, Arora has been impressed with the iPad mini’s size, which allows her to put it in a lab coat, hold it in one hand and even store it in a purse. The nimble iPad mini dimensions were also cited with Arora admitting that she carried the iPad mini around more than the 9.7-inch iPad, which she describes as "hard to carry".

Arora says that interest in the iPad mini has seen her make new friends in the hospital, to the point where she met one nurse who later came to the physician’s rescue in helping a patient.

However, the iPad mini is not without its pitfalls in the healthcare environment, according to Arora, with the tablet easy to lose and hard to see for the visually impaired.

“If you are in your Citrix Client looking at your electronic health record, it may not be so easy to magnify and you may have to hold it up closer to your face, which can be awkward,” she said.

But perhaps the biggest problem with the iPad mini is the lack of a keyboard, with Arora suggesting that its absence prevents the small Apple tablet from becoming a “complete substitute for a workstation or pen and paper”.

“This is not unique to the Mini. There is a reason that mobile tablet computing is not a complete substitute for a workstation – the lack of a keyboard.

“As a result, some our residents carry “paper notes” with their iPad – the paper notes are to take notes of the to-do list that is created on rounds. The iPad does not replace that so readily.

So, what could the answer be for physicians and tablet computing in healthcare? Arora, who is associate professor of medicine at The University of Chicago's department of medicine, argues that Microsoft’s Surface tablet has a chance.

“I have to admit, watching the catchy commercial for the Windows Surface, there is still something so appealing about an external keyboard.”

Links & Apps

Share with: Comments (3)    v

Free newsletters for more tablet news, insights, apps and tips


  • davidthomsan
    1 year 9 months ago

    Everyone that touches my iPad mini falls in love with it. Even people that had no interest in the gadgets I purchase were instantly allured by its tiny aluminum body. There’s something about this device that just makes you want to hold it and I’ve had to pry it out of people’s hands to get it back.

  • Dine6
    1 year 10 months ago

    There are tons of keyboard cases for the mini. They may add a bit to the weight, but the size remains essentially the same, so the tablet can be held in one hand, can be put into a (fairly large) pocket, or will still fit handily in a purse. The keyboard will of course be smaller than one is used to on a PC or laptop, but it will undoubtedly be easier to type on than the virtual keyboard.

  • scottclandis
    1 year 10 months ago

    But to use the Surface with the keyboard you need to find a table or chair to set the device up to work on, basically creating a work station. At that point why aren't you just using a work station? And you want to talk about heavy and awkward to carry? The doctor has obviously never picked up a Surface.

Latest in tablet business / productivity